We accept all insurance — no DRP contractsCall (623) 931-2110

Blog · Insurance

Can I Change Collision Repair Shops After My Car Is Already Towed to One?

You are never locked into using a collision repair shop just because your vehicle was towed there from an accident scene or pressured into it by an insurance company.

You Have the Legal Right to Transfer Your Vehicle

Arizona law gives you the absolute right to choose where your vehicle is repaired, even if it is already sitting at another shop's facility. Many West Valley drivers feel stuck if their insurer had the vehicle towed directly to one of their "preferred" Direct Repair Program (DRP) facilities. These DRP shops have contracts with insurers to keep costs down, often by using alternative parts or skipping necessary repair procedures. If you realize the shop your car was towed to does not align with your best interests, you can halt the process and have it moved to an independent shop that prioritizes your safety.

What Fees Must Be Paid Before a Shop Releases Your Car?

The original shop will not release your vehicle until all outstanding fees for towing, storage, and any completed diagnostic work are paid in full. If the vehicle was towed there and sat for a few days, there will be daily storage charges and potentially a gate fee. If they did a teardown or a pre-scan, they will bill for that labor. These expenses typically must be cleared before the vehicle can be moved:

  • Towing charges from the accident scene to the first shop.
  • Daily storage fees accrued while the vehicle sat on their lot.
  • Diagnostic scanning fees or teardown labor if they started assessing damage.
  • Administrative or release fees charged by the initial facility.

How to Handle the Transfer Process Safely

To move your vehicle to Liberty Collision Center, you must first instruct the current shop in writing to stop all work immediately. Do not let them perform any structural repairs or teardowns once you have made your decision. Next, contact our team; we frequently help West Valley drivers navigate shop transfers, coordinate the payment of release fees, and arrange for a flatbed tow to our Glendale facility.

If you want to move your vehicle away from an insurance-preferred shop to an independent team that works for you, call Liberty Collision Center at (623) 931-2110. We will coordinate the vehicle transfer and handle the paperwork.

Will Insurance Cover the Cost of Moving Your Car?

Whether your insurance policy covers a second tow and the initial shop's release fees depends on your policy language and the specifics of the claim, as policy terms and local laws vary. If you were pressured or misled into sending your vehicle to a DRP shop, or if that shop cannot perform proper OEM repairs and ADAS calibrations, we can assist you in advocating to your insurer to cover these transfer costs. However, even if you have to pay a small release fee out of pocket, it is often worth it to ensure your vehicle undergoes proper structural repairs rather than a compromised, insurance-driven repair.

Common Questions

Can a body shop hold my car hostage if I want to switch?

A shop cannot legally refuse to release your vehicle if you demand it, but they can hold it until you pay for services already rendered. Once towing, storage, or authorized diagnostic fees are settled, they must release the vehicle immediately. We can help you coordinate with the shop to ensure they do not overcharge you during the release.

What if the first shop already started taking my car apart?

You can still move your vehicle even if a teardown has begun. You will need to pay the first shop for the labor hours spent on the teardown, and the vehicle will need to be flatbed-towed to our shop with its disassembled parts carefully boxed and documented. We will inventory the parts upon arrival to ensure nothing was left behind.

Will switching shops delay my insurance claim?

Transferring your vehicle can add a few days to the overall timeline due to towing coordination and processing release fees. However, getting a proper, safe repair with OEM parts and correct ADAS calibration from an independent shop is always safer than dealing with a poorly executed repair that has to be corrected later.

Call Liberty Before You Make a Decision

If your insurance company is telling you where to take your car, your vehicle is sitting in an impound lot, or your claim is being delayed — call us first. We'll explain your options.